Frogsleap Farm

Frogsleap Farm

Saturday, January 25, 2014

Hybrid vs O.P. tomato varieties


Tomato hybrids are F1 crosses between two stable inbred lines.  Since tomatoes are primarily self-pollinated, O.P. (open-pollinated) varieties are stable inbred lines – with perhaps a little variability from low level chance outcrossing.

The vast majority of all of the commercial tomato production in the world is with F1 hybrids, whether the hybrids are designed for processing or fresh market use.   Higher fruit yield in F1 hybrids is probably the biggest driver here, but stacking disease resistance genes is another benefit.  Since most commercial breeding companies are breeding for traits other than flavor – most F1 hybrids, with a few outstanding exceptions, are lousy in that regard.

Heirloom types, developed over many generations by families and/or communities, have been selected primarily for flavor.  These are all O.P. types, though I know there are some companies talking about heirloom hybrids - heirloom x heirloom I suppose.  Heirloom varieties typically have their own set of challenges: low yield, disease susceptibility, short shelf life, and/or fruit quality (cracking/catfacing, etc.) problems.

In the last several years several breeders have begun crossing commercial hybrids with heirloom types to get the best of both worlds – but that’s a different story.

As a tomato breeder I see intrinsic advantages in F1 hybrids – some obvious, others not.

Hybrid vigor or heterosis.   This is usually simply defined as performance in the F1 that is better than either of the parents.   Numerous scientific studies report, and commercial tomato breeders have demonstrated the potential for heterosis for fruit yield, and there is substantial evidence of heterosis for other
traits (reference; pages 115-127), including sugar and acid content - key drivers for flavor (reference).  We make several dozen new F1 crosses every year and in many cases we see exceptional flavor in the F1 generation that we never successfully stabilize in succeeding filial generations.  Several years ago my friend Bill Jeffers sent me seed of a F1 cross he made (Indian Stripe x Sungold).  Flavor in the F1 generation was out of this world, and to our mutual disappointment we were never able to capture anything close to this in F5/F6 lines.  Another breeder friend Keith Mueller has commercialized the F1 hybrid “Purple Haze” derived from a cross between Black Cherry and a (Brandywine x Cherokee Purple) line he developed.  He says that this specific combination demonstrates heterosis for flavor that stands out from other similar crosses he tested.  In 2016 we tested ~60 hybrids and the corresponding parent lines in both open field and greenhouse trials in Wisconsin.  There was clear heterosis for both fruit yield and flavor - and a handful of parent lines with great general and specific combining ability for flavor, as judged by our 3-4 person tasting team.  


    Stacking disease resistance traits.  Wild relatives of tomatoes have been a rich source of genes for resistance/tolerance to key tomato diseases.  With few exceptions these disease resistant genes are inherited as dominant alleles – e.g. Resistant x Susceptible = Resistant.  In a F1 hybrid typically one parent will be resistant to one set of diseases (e.g. ABC), the other resistant to another set of diseases (e.g. DEF) with the hybrid then resistant to both sets of diseases (e.g. ABCDEF).  This has proven to be a very effective way of stacking disease resistance generally in tomato varieties, and an absolute requirement when trying to combine traits that are linked in repulsion phase, e.g. resistance to late blight and tomato spotted wilt virus.

Some genes are desired in the heterozygous state.  In inbred (i.e. O.P.) lines the plants are homozygous at virtually all loci.  For a particular gene/locus the heterozygous condition is only possible in a hybrid, or an unstable segregating population.  The recessive rin allele is involved in fruit ripening.  In the homozygous state the fruit never ripens, in the heterozygous state (rin/+) there is delayed ripening of the fruit, providing extended shelf life (reference).  Many of the vine ripened tomatoes (cherry, grape and cluster) now being marketed in grocery stores are rin/+ F1 hybrids.  The NC State rin/+ hybrid Mountain Magic is an excellent example of a tasty tomato with exceptional shelf life (and state of the art multiple disease resistance).   More recently a discovery was reported that a loss of function mutant allele in the gene SFT, which codes for the flowering hormone florigen, had a profound effect on plant growth in tomatoes.  Homozygous sft/sft plants had significantly delayed flowering and low yield, heterozygous plants sft/+ (in determinate plants)  had 60% higher yield (photo above) and enhanced flavor (reference).


New F1 hybrid (Aft/+)
Complementary traits.  Some of our best inbred lines absolutely nail some traits (e.g. flavor and/or fruit type), but have one or more key weaknesses (e.g. splitting, poor seed yield, late fruiting or plant architecture).  By selecting hybrid parents that compliment each other for key traits, we’ve identified F1 hybrids that are clearly superior to the parents.  This is perhaps another ramification of the heterosis discussion above.

There are only two disadvantages of hybrids vs O.P. varieties that I can think of:  a) seed production is more complicated, more expensive and grower saved seed is not an option; and b) a significant portion of the customer base for tasty locally grown (homegrown or farmers markets) fresh market tomatoes has an anti–hybrid bias, unfortunately often confounding F1 hybrids with GMO traits, organic vs conventional, or big biz vs family owned operations. 

Frogsleap Farm is a two person husband and wife breeding team, working with the best heirloom and commercial hybrid germplasm we can find, and developing novel varieties (including F1 hybrids) for both organic and conventional producers.   We think both F1 hybrids and O.P. varieties will have a place in an exciting marketplace of unique and tasty tomato varieties adapted for use by home gardeners and small to medium sized tomato producers.

Saturday, June 9, 2012

Siberian Tiger F4

My friend Blane, in Alabama, has a tomato season that starts a few months ahead of us - so he gets a first look at the various breeding lines he's helping to evaluate.  Here are a couple of photos of fruit in the F4 generation of Siberian Tiger (from our cross OSU Blue x Beauty King).  Not only is Blane a skilled grower and keen observer - he's lucky, often finding just the segregating variant we are looking for.  Thanks Blane!  Photos by Blane Horton.

The classic Siberian Tiger stripes in unripe fruit

Segregation in the F4 - the one on the left is what we are after

August 2013 update - unfortunately neither Blane nor I could stabilize the striking F4 phenotype (on the left).  I had shared seed of the original "tiger striped" F2 with a handful of people and one or more of the early generation lines was commercialized under the name Siberian Tiger.  These show variable phenotypes, none of which appear to capture my original product concept - so it goes.  Some good news however ...


This is a F6 segregate from my original breeding cross, found this summer in our Pennsylvania nursery.  To avoid any confusion the working name for this line is Bengal Tiger, more on stability next year.

Monday, April 30, 2012

Good Zebra, Bad Zebra


What prompted this post was my finding of a pair of zebra mussel encrusted sunglasses on the beach of our local lake last week.  Zebra mussels are a recently introduced invasive species that, despite best efforts, are proliferating in many local Minnesota lakes.   They are hyper competitive and in a short period of time have become a dominant species in the lake.  Bad Zebra. 

Bad Zebra 
For tomato lovers the tomato variety Green Zebra is something many of us now take for granted.  It was developed by Tom Wagner over 30 years ago and released in 1983.  It sometimes called an heirloom, and Tom is often not given credit for the breeding.  He combined the green stripe gene (gs) and an interesting tasting green when ripe (GWR) background through a series of crosses over many years of breeding.  Green Zebra was a founder source for Brad Gates and other breeders that have combined stripes and great taste as a way to introduce novel looking and tasty tomatoes.  On Tom’s New World Seeds website you can now buy seed of his reselected Green Zebra - we planted it this year.  Good Zebra.

Here are a few newer lines tracing in part to Green Zebra; Michael Pollan, a great striped GWR GZ derivative from Brad Gates; our MP x Cowlicks F1 (photo by Blane Horton); and three F2 segregants from that same cross. 

Michael Pollan
MP x Cowlicks Brandywine F1
F2 segregants MP x Cowlicks

Friday, January 6, 2012

Pandora's Box


We used to think there were pretty predictable combinations of skin/flesh color in tomatoes, and that with a few exceptions the epidermis color (yellow vs clear) was simply a subtle tinting of the window through which one viewed flesh color.  Over the last couple of years, and this year especially, we’ve found a number of surprises when we sliced into a new variety or breeding line.  When you open Pandora’s Box – be prepared for something unexpected …. and delightful. 





Aft skin peel
An obvious exception to the conventional skin color/flesh color rules are the new tomato lines with anthocyanin accumulation in the fruit - Aft (see the blog on this site “Breeding the Blue Tomato).  In the presence of light the anthocyanin pigment accumulates in and just below the fruit epidermis.  This trait has now been introgressed into a number of genetic backgrounds with red, pink, purple, brown, and bicolor fleshed types.  I haven’t seen an Aft GWR fruit yet, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist, or that it won’t pop out in someone’s breeding line in 2012.  It’s on our priority list.  Thanks again to Professor Jim Meyers and his grad students at OSU for developing the background Aft/atv germplasm.  They have just released a new Aft variety “Indigo Rose” that you might want to check out, it’s available from several seed sellers.


Red pigment beneath epidermis
There are other examples of the accumulation of a contrasting pigment just beneath the epidermis.  In a large fruited cherry line now breeding true for this trait (suggesting it is likely recessive), there is a thin layer of bright red pigmentation just beneath the yellow epidermis.  The result is a dark orange fruit that when sliced shows the red layer overlying yellow flesh.  It’s an interesting look in a very tasty line now with multiple F4 sisters, with and without the green stripe (gs) trait.

This phenomenon is even more striking on a new F1 plant (from a three way cross) we found this year.  This odd looking tomato has a relatively drab dark yellowish brown appearance on the outside, caused by another underlying layer of pigment which in this case, shields a brilliant light green flesh.  We are anxiously awaiting the F2 generation next year.  The working name for this striped beauty is Pandora’s Box, but there’s a lot of work ahead to stabilize this unique phenotype …. more on this later.

Pandora's Box

inside Pandora's Box

This year we grew Millard Murdoch’s Captain Lucky, a stable line with purple skin and GWR bicolor flesh, and several plants of Bill Jeffer’s segregating F3 “Wild Thyme” which also had interesting combinations of skin color and flesh color (mostly bicolor types).  These were both a little late for this season and this latitude – but even late in the season these both tasted pretty darned good.  We are crossing plants of both to some earlier breeding lines.


Wild Thyme F3

We’ve long had a fondness for bicolor/tricolor types, and now have several breeding lines with striking bi/tri color combinations and veins of color (mostly red) sometimes bleeding out to just below the epidermis, and significantly affecting coloration of the fruit surface.  In our lines this tendency is combined with gs and/or fruit stripe (Fs) making the fruit color combinations quite amazing.  Brad Gate’s Berkeley Tie Dye and Beauty Queen were inspirations for this effort, and for our breeding work generally. 
Striped bicolor

My friend Carolyn Male reminded me that the opening of the mythical Pandora’s Box unleashed evil surprises into the world.  In the case of these breeding lines, and this phenomenon generally in tomatoes, we like the “box full of surprises” metaphor, but with the surprises being a source of delight that continues to undermine the red and round, firm but tasteless super-market tomato model, and giving rise to an exciting opportunity for artisan tomato breeders, growers and sellers.  Happy New Year.

A January 15 update:  thanks to the real-time feedback made possible by the web - Julien posts as a comment, a photo of a GWR Aft tomato.  It looks like the photo link ties to Tom Wagner's blogspot, so I am assuming it is a segregent from one of his Aft lines.  I apologize I cannot give proper attribution to the photo.

Sunday, November 20, 2011

Fountain of Youth


Feeling the minor aches and pains of growing older?  Ponce de Leon’s pursuit of the Fountain of Youth has obvious attractions to us “baby boomers”, but a sprinkling of the magic water on tomatoes would also be nice.

We’ve long been frustrated by the often lightning fast transition from fully ripe to over-ripe fruit that is characteristic of many heirloom tomato varieties.  The window for peak flavor/texture can be somewhere between several hours to a couple of days.  Our friend and tomato guru Brad Gates calls this the "melting popsicle".  To compound the problem, just when the fruit approach peak ripeness they also start their most fickle period for cracking/splitting.  It’s bad enough for the backyard gardner who can pick daily and simply carry them into the kitchen, but for market growers even picking and distribution for local markets is tough with most heirloom types.  Fortunately there are genetic tools for breeders to extend “shelf life” of tomatoes. 

The technology for long shelf life (LSL) tomatoes has been around for decades.   This started with Calgene’s failed commercial attempt at LSL in which they used genetic engineering to down-regulate a gene coding for an enzyme (polygalacturonase) involved in fruit softening (FlavrSavr).  This was followed shortly thereafter by the discovery of naturally occuring (non-GE) mutations in several transcription factors regulating various genes/pathways involved in fruit maturation/ripening (e.g rin, nor and Nr) - a review article can be found here.  There are a number of new GE approaches as well, one of which is referenced, but not discussed here.
A tasty rin/rin cherry breeding line


                                 +/+                           +/rin                               rin/rin

rin/rin w/ crimson for enhanced color - NCSU photo

The “rin” allele, is a mutation in a gene that regulates ethylene biosynthesis and specific plant responses to ethylene (reference).   The plant hormone ethylene is a trigger for a cascade of physiological changes associated with fruit ripening.  The recessive “ripening inhibitor” (rin) allele in it’s homozygous state prevents normal ripening of the fruit.  A rin phenotype at peak ripeness has mature seed, but without normal fruit coloration or fruit softening.  These fruit tend to be crispy, green/yellow, and without much flavor.  In the heterozygote state +/rin the fruit will ripen to normal color and flavor, but on a delayed timeline and maintaining the “ripe” phenotype for an extended period of time – thus, LSL (reference).  The rin technology was discovered in the 1980’s and patented soon thereafter.  It is currently off-patent and widely used by commercial tomato breeders developing “vine-ripened” hybrid cherry, grape and cluster tomatoes, produced in Mexico and marketed in the U.S. every month of the year.  It is a breeding challenge to combine +/rin (only possible in hybrids) with normal fruit color and exceptional flavor – but Mountain Magic and several others have cleared this hurdle.   We are in the early stages of developing parents for great tasting, great looking, LSL “rin” hybrids that incorporate best-in-class flavor from heirlooms, and LSL, crack/splitting resistance, and multiple disease resistance from commercial hybrids.

In addition to the novel alleles for genes affecting normal fruit ripening, there are other components to LSL (reference).  Fruit firmness is intimately related to LSL and is significantly impacted by epidermins/epicarp composition/toughness, strength of pericarp cell walls and connections between cells in the pericarp.  The ratio of pericarp to locular material also seems to effect firmness.  A “tougher” epidermis also helps resist cracking/splitting.  There is significant genetic variation for all of these traits.  Ofcourse there is a caution here, a fruit can be too firm or have skin that is too tough.  Moderation is the key – finding the “sweet spot” in fruit firmness/skin toughness that helps fruit quality but doesn’t negatively impact taste and mouth feel.

While commercial tomato breeders have done an excellent job improving fruit firmness and LSL, it has often been at the expense of fruit flavor.  The NCSU release “Mountain Magic” and the new U of Florida “TastiLee” are two examples of good tasting new hybrids combining these multiple favorable traits, but we think there is a lot of opportunity in this area for artisan breeders.

Non-splitting striped cherry
We have F3/F4 striped cherries with great taste and virtually bomb proof for cracking – even after a rain.  These new cherries also have better hang time on the vine.  We are a little farther out on rin lines, but making progress.  All of these LSL breeding lines are derived from crosses between our heirloom-derived breeding lines and commerial hybrids, so we are also picking up multiple disease resistance.  Last year we made crosses to a couple of larger fruited commercial rin hybrids, and have F2 growouts this winter.

GVS 51800 - commercial LSL hybrid used in crossing
The goal is to add a few days of shelf life and better crack resistance to heirloom-derived varities – that are fun to look at and great tasting.  We’ll be posting updates.


January 2012 photo from the greenhouse: a F1 fruit from a striped cherry x GVS 51800 cross.  Fruit size similar to GVS 51800, with more pronounced stripes than I expected in a gs/+ plant.  This is one of several F1's from such crosses that will go to the field as F2 progeny next summer.

                 ---------------------------

October 2012 update - several good selections from the GVS F2s - all w/ stripes.  Also many new crosses to Tasti Lee.







November 2012 photo of fruit of three crosses to our rin/rin cherry.  The larger two are almost ripe.  Ripe fruit stage on a rin/rin line is a dull green yellow.  The rin/+ hybrid will have normal color and the desired delayed ripening/long shelf life (LSL) characteristics.  Next summer we should have the rin gene introgressed into several of our best breeding lines.








August 2013 update - progeny tracing to crosses between FLF x commercial hybrids are looking very good.  We are seeing much improved fruit quality (e.g. tolerance to cracking and improved shelf life) combined with stripes and exceptional flavor.  This photo of a fruit from a F2 plant heterozygous for both gs and rin - and with great taste.  FLF parent was Pandora's Box, so we should a wide variety of flesh and skin color combos in future generations from this cross.


Thursday, April 7, 2011

Building with Brix

Although tomato fanatics will argue on relative taste of various tomato varieties, it is generally recognized that there are three major components to taste in tomatoes: sugar content, acidity, and volatile flavor compounds (reference).  The right balance of sweetness and acidity is crucial, but generally higher sugar content makes  for better tasting tomatoes (reference). Sugars are the predominant component of soluble solids in tomatoes.  Soluble solids content (Brix units) is easily measured with a hand held refractometer. 

Brix level in most tomato varieties varies between 4-6%, with popular cherry hybrids like SunGold and Sweet Million being notably higher.  To boost soluble solids content in tomatoes, breeders have recently incorporated genes from wild relatives.  This has resulted in a new generation of super sweet tomato hybrid cherry and grape types with reported >10% Brix.  Many of these new hybrids also contain the rin gene for longer shelf life, and have improved resistance to fruit cracking.  Seed for most of these is only available to commercial growers, so thanks to my various Tomatoville friends for helping us to access seed this winter.

This summer we are growing out F1 and/or F2 generation plants of several new super sweet grape/mini-plum hybrids for crossing to our best striped cherries, saladettes, plums, hearts and beefsteak types.  We hope to incorporate higher Brix, longer shelf life and improved disease resistance from the commercial hybrids to our “heirloom derived” breeding lines.
  
TGRC photo
A particular TGRC accession of S. galapagense (L.cheesmanii minor) from the Galapagos Islands has been reportedly widely used as a breeding source for high soluble solids.  In this research study (publication link) LA530 tips the scales at 13% Brix, more than double any of the commercial cultivar checks.  We are also growing this beast this summer, probably making a few crosses, but mostly out of curiosity.  Note the strikingly different fruit type.  Seedling vigor is also unique, and not in a good way.  An interesting side note is that LA530 also has high salt tolerance and under salty conditions gets even a little sweeter!

Taste is not all about Brix, but we are betting high Brix is a good building block for improved flavor (pun intended).  We should have F2 populations from these new crosses to taste test in 2012.

Saturday, March 5, 2011

Breeding for the Blue Tomato



Our darkest F2 fruit
Blue tomatoes, not really - the fruit are really more of an indigo color; the pigmentation more like an eggplant.  So what's the fuss about and what's the genetic basis for the accumulation of anthocyanin pigment in tomato fruit?  Here's what we've learned from the literature and from our experience in breeding for the trait.


In the last several years there’s been significant interest in breeding tomatoes with improved nutritional quality.  One approach has been to increase fruit concentration of anthocyanin and related phenolic compounds that also have anti-oxidant activity.  Professor Jim Meyers, and various graduate students working with him at Oregon State University (including Jones, Mes, Boches and Dalotto), have used TGRC lines to introgress, into cultivated tomato, two genes from wild relatives that independently regulate anthocyanin synthesis in tomato fruit.  This group has published most of what is known about the genetic basis for the trait (see Jones, 2003 link).  We are among a group of several tomato breeders working on incorporating these genes into various tomato breeding lines.  The Aft/atv parent we used in crossing was a single plant selected in our breeding nursery from OSU Blue for intense anthocyanin accumulation in the fruit and acceptable horticultural type.  Taste of this OSU Blue "donor plant" was not very good.

Aft fruit cross section - pigmentation
accumulation limited to surface
layers of cells  (P. Boches photo)
The Aft (anthocyanin fruit) gene, from S. chilense, is a regulatory gene (An2 transcription factor) that is induced by UV light and that triggers up-regulation of anthocyanin biosynthesis in tomato fruit, and to a lesser extent in vegetative tissue.  In Aft plants anthocyanin accumulates in and just below the fruit epidermis, where light penetrates the first few layer of cells.  It is believed that such accumulation is a stress and protection response to UV light (think melanin accumulation in human skin cells in response to UV light – tanning).  Typically those parts of the fruit exposed to light will accumulate anthocyanin and turn black/purple, while those parts of the fruit not exposed to light will have the normal background fruit color.  Anthocyanin accumulation begins very early during the green fruit stage and masks normal fruit color in mature fruit.  Anthocyanin appears to accumulate preferentially in the green stripes of gs and Fs fruit.

 Todd Dalotto photo
The atv (atroviolaceum) gene, from S. cheesmaniae, induces anthocyanin accumulation in vegetative tissue and, in combination with Aft, to anthocyanin accumulation in tomato fruit.  Plants homozygous for atv accumulate anthocyanin in leaves, stems and petioles, especially in conditions with high light and cool temperatures. 

Co-expression of Aft and atv have a synergistic effect on fruit anthocyanin production (see Povero 2012 link).  For this reason a breeding program for anthocyanin accumulation in tomato fruit needs to select for both Aft and atv.  Here’s what we have learned from evaluating several hundred plants from six F2 populations segregating for both Aft and tav:

Under cool high light conditions seedlings homozygous for atv will begin accumulating anthocyanin in the cotyledons and the epicotyl.  This accumulation will become more obvious as the seedlings get larger.  Maintaining cool temperatures and high light is critical for successful selection of atv/atv seedlings at this stage.
F2 seedlings segregating for
pigmentation in cotyledons

This dark purple PL seedling did not produce
fruit w/ any anthocyanin pigmentation

Once the seedlings establish in the field and the temperatures increase, the anthocyanin accumulation in leaves/stems fades quickly.  Later in the season when the temperature begins to drop, anthocyanin accumulation in vegetative tissue (especially growing points) starts anew.

Differences in pigmentation at transplanting within a F2 family,
each selected weeks earlier for seedling "purpling"

Some of seedlings with the darkest “purple” foliage had no anthocyanin accumulation in the fruit (atv positive/Aft negative).  In fact there was no significant relationship between seedling score for anthocyanin and anthocyanin accumulation in fruit.  This was a surprise, and suggests not being too rigorous in screening seedlings.  In 2010 we selected < 5% of the F2 seedlings for transplanting – based on the anthocyanin phenotype in seedlings.  This is probably more severe than needed.  Among seedlings showing some anthocyanin acculation, there is a considerable variation in degree of purpling (see photo above).  This may be an interaction between atv and Aft or other unknown genes.




Early fruit pigmentation 

Pigmentation is local and only where fruit is exposed
to direct sunlight
Anthocyanin shading on the sunny side of this F2 fruit
4    Anthocyanin accumulation in fruit (primarily due to Aft) begins very early in fruit development – but only in young fruit exposed to light.  Because early fruit is often deep in the canopy, we do some early pruning to improve light exposure, enabling the Aft phenotype.  Late in the season, with better fruit exposure to sunlight and cooler temperatures, we saw stronger expression of the Aft phenotype.
5    Among F2 segregants showing some anthocyanin accumulation in fruit, there was very significant variation in early season intensity of the pigment, and how sensitive such accumulation was to light.  Part of this may be due to whether Aft was homozygous vs heterozygous (i.e. partial dominance – suggested by Jones), but it appears there may also be interactions with other unknown genes.  We should learn more from the F3 generation.

Our best tasting F2 - a bicolor orange w/ indigo highlights

6    In the F2 generation there didn’t appear to be any relationship between anthocyanin accumulation in the fruit and flavor/taste.  Taste of fruit from the best F2 plants with a strong Aft fruit phenotype were 7.5-8.0 on a scale of 10.  There’s still some work to do here.  This year we will have F3 progeny from the best Aft lines and backcrosses of these to our best tasting non-Aft breeding lines.
Aft/gs

Indigo striped cherry


      As described in our “Genetic control of fruit stripes” blog, we saw a preferential accumulation of anthocyanin in green stripes in fruit of F2 plants co-segregating for gs and Fs.  This should yield some pretty interesting and novel looking F3 fruit in Aft/gs  and atv/gs plants with various fruit color/shape combinations.  Purple Dragon is Dean Slater's name for a F3 line combining Aft/gs.  Black and Brown Boar was the striped parent in the F1, which I think is evident here.

Late season w/ plenty of light exposure to fruit and cooler temperature


High pigment mutants hp1 and hp2 dg are lesions in regulatory genes (transcription factors) that regulate light-signaling in tomatoes.  Homozygous hp plants show several novel developmental and metabolic phenotypes, including increased fruit pigmentation and accumulation of various flavonoid phytonutrients.  A combination of hp1 or hp2 dg with Aft and atv show >20x enhanced anthocyanin accumulation in tomato fruit, see photo here.  The hp  phenotype generally also results in negative effects on plant vigor and fruit yield.  The combination of hp and Aft/atv is subject to a U.S. patent application (patent application link).


----------------------------------------------------------------------

Here's a 2012/13 update.  With a few exceptions it appears that to get exceptional flavor in an Aft/atv line it will require two generations of crossing (a cross and a backcross/modifed backcross) of P20 to a high flavor parent.  We have several nice MBC1 lines now in the breeding program  One exception is the Indigo Tiger cherry shown above and now in the F5.  In 2012 I planted the new OSU release Indigo Rose (OSU press release).  Good anthocyanin expression but flavor was just fair, not good enough for me to want to plant again.  I've also tried several of Tom Wagner's Aft lines and found a few interesting plants in these widely segregating populations.  One of the best was a green when ripe (GWR) line with anthocyanin stripes, from a line he called Muddy Waters.  We used this in several crosses in 2012, and some interesting F2s from these in 2013.


Selection from Muddy Waters
MW x GWR breeding line - F2
We had a chance to visit Brad Gates (Wild Boar Farms) in 2012 and he had several Aft/atv lines, including a couple of ours.  Here's a photo from his nursery of an Aft line tracing to a breeding line of ours we call Freckled Strawberry.  Note the indigo freckles and shoulder on this unripe fruit.  The bottom photo is from a similar Aft Freckled Stawberry line from our 2013 Pennsylvania nursery - top fruit from within the canopy (no light, no anthocyanin) and bottom fruit exposed to light on one side with anthocyanin present.


Aft Freckled Strawberry

We've found another interesting manifestation of Aft/atv in a segregating breeding line tracing to our cross P20 x Beauty King.  Note the "tiger stripes" pattern.  Although we are yet unable to stabilize the phenotype, anthocyanin accumulates in lateral stripes on developing and ripe fruit (coexpression w/ Fs gene).  The Fs phenotype appears to be highly influenced by environment, complicating the breeding.  This photo is also from our 2013 Pennsylvania nursery - nickname for now is Bengal Tiger
.
Bengal Tiger